Political commentator Alinur Mohamed has ignited fresh debate following a fiery response to Kapseret MP Oscar Sudi’s criticism of the Echoes of War play staged by students from Butere Girls High School. In a pointed online jab, Alinur wrote, “I don’t blame you. If you read a set book in high school, you would have understood.” His sarcastic comment quickly went viral, stirring a heated national conversation on politics, education, and the role of art in society.
The Play That Sparked Controversy
Echoes of War, a thought-provoking drama piece authored by former UDA Secretary General Cleophas Malala, is said to be heavily inspired by the 2023 Gen Z protests against the controversial Finance Bill. The play captures themes of resistance, injustice, and the voice of the youth — themes that echo real-world events in Kenya’s political landscape.
The performance was abruptly halted when students protested against alleged police intimidation, demanding that Malala be present before continuing with the show. This act of solidarity highlighted just how seriously the students took their art — and its message.
Oscar Sudi’s Criticism — and the Backlash
Oscar Sudi had earlier dismissed the play, labeling it as politically charged and inappropriate for a school setting. However, critics argue that Sudi’s interpretation reveals a lack of understanding of literature and its power. Alinur Mohamed was among the loudest voices pushing back against this view, implying that Sudi’s comments stemmed from a lack of literary education.
“Literature Isn’t for Everyone,” Says Alinur
Alinur’s comment was more than just a clapback — it was a broader commentary on the disconnect between art and politics. He emphasized that literature and drama serve as mirrors to society and are essential tools for shaping public discourse. According to him, those who never engaged with literature during their school years may struggle to understand such nuanced performances.
Final Thoughts: Understand Before You Criticize
At the heart of this debate lies a critical question: Should creative expression be censored because it makes us uncomfortable, or should it be embraced as a catalyst for dialogue and change? Alinur Mohamed’s message was simple but powerful — before condemning creative work, seek to understand its meaning. The Echoes of War controversy serves as a national wake-up call, exposing the growing divide between artistic expression and political interpretation in Kenya today.
